homehome Home chatchat Notifications


“Ugly” reef fish are more endangered than “pretty” ones and it's a problem

Humans are shaping nature based on their own preference -- and this preference is sometimes very unhealthy.

Fermin Koop
June 9, 2022 @ 12:42 am

share Share

The reef fish that people describe as most aesthetically pleasing are in fact the ones that need the least conservation support, while the fish that are ranked as “ugly” are the most endangered species, according to a new study. This difference between aesthetic value and extinction vulnerability could have long-term consequences on biodiversity conservation.

The Queen Angelfish, one of the “pretty” ones. Image credit: Wikipedia Commons.

Researchers from the University of Montpellier in France measured the aesthetic value of over 2,400 reef fish (fish that lives near coral reefs). Aesthetic value is one of the most direct emotional links humans can experience with nature but it’s also a poorly studied phenomenon, despite the implications it seems to have for biodiversity conservation.

“There is a need for us to make sure that our ‘natural’ aesthetic biases do not turn into a bias of conservation effort,” Nicolas Mouquet, one of the lead study authors, said in a statement. “Our study highlights likely important mismatches between potential public support for conservation and the species most in need of this support.”

Pretty vs not pretty

The researchers first carried out an online survey in which over 13,000 people rated the aesthetic value of 480 photos of ray-finned reef fish. Then they fed this data into an artificial intelligence system, enabling them to generate predictions for how people would have rated a total of 2,417 of the most commonly known reef fish species.

The combined results showed that the bright, colorful, and round-bodied fish species, such as the queen angelfish (Holacanthus ciliaris) and the striped cowfish (Aracana aurita), were more frequently ranked as “beautiful”. But these are also the “less evolutionary distinct” species, meaning they are genetically similar to other fish.

On the contrary, fish species that ranked lower in the aesthetic rankings and were seen as “uglier” by the public, like the drab fish (Achirus achirus), with no clearly delineated color patterns, were also more ecologically distinct, at a larger ecological risk and listed as “threatened” by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).

File:Achirus declivis.png
Achirus achirus. Image credits: Carla Isobel Elliff.

The problem goes way beyond fish species. Previous studies have found aesthetics are the reason why mammals, fish, and reptiles (vertebrates) receive more conservation focus compared to insects, spiders, and worms (invertebrates). A 2020 study found vertebrates get six times more investment in conservation efforts than invertebrates.

For the researchers, further studies in this area could help researchers anticipate the consequences of species loss and also implement better communication strategies to tackle this issue with policymakers, conservation organizations, and the overall public. They might be “ugly” to the human eye, but we also have to properly protect them.

The study was published in the journal PLOS Biology.

share Share

The World's Oldest Known Ant Is A 113-Million-Year-Old Hell Ant with Scythe Jaws

A remarkable find for ant history was made, not in the field but in a drawer.

Your Cells Can Hear You — And It Could Be Important for Fat Cells

Researchers explore the curious relationship between sound and gene expression in cell cultures.

16,000-Year-Old Dog-Like Skeleton Found in France Raises Haunting Questions

Cared for like a companion, or killed like prey?

Japanese Scientists Just Summoned Lightning with a Drone. Here’s Why

The drone is essentially a mobile, customizable, lightning rod.

Tiny Chinese Satellite Sent Hack-Proof Quantum Messages 12,900 Kilometers Through Space. Is a Quantum Internet Around the Corner?

The US and Europe are now racing to catch up to China.

Cats Came Bearing Gods: Religion and Trade Shaped the Rise of the Domestic Cat in Europe

Two groundbreaking studies challenge the old narrative that cats followed early farmers into Europe.

The People of Carthage Weren’t Who We Thought They Were

The Punic people had almost no genetic ties to Phoenicians, even though the latter founded the great city of Carthage.

RFK Jr loves raw milk. Now, he's suspending milk quality tests due to Trump cuts

Imagine pouring a glass of milk for your child and wondering if it’s safe.

A Roman gladiator died fighting a lion in England and his 1,800-year-old skeleton proves it

It's the first-ever evidence of man-lion combat found in the Roman period.

This Surprising Protein Shift Could Add Years to Your Life, Study Finds

A global study ties plant protein to longer adult lives, but early life needs differ.