homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Step aside sommeliers, this AI is writing reviews

New algorithm writes reviews that sound like they were done by human critics

Fermin Koop
May 3, 2022 @ 10:32 pm

share Share

Consider the following wine review: “This is a sound Cabernet. It’s very dry and a little thin in blackberry fruit, which accentuates the acidity and tannins. Drink up.”

It reads like the kind of descriptive, evocative writing you’d expect from a wine critic. But there’s a catch: it was actually written by an algorithm.

Image credit: Pixabay.

A group of researchers from Dartmouth University have developed an artificial intelligence algorithm that can write wine (and beer) reviews that are almost indistinguishable from those written by a human critic. It’s not just for giggles — this could help beer and wine producers aggregate reviews and give human reviewers a template to work from, they argued.

“Using artificial intelligence to write and synthesize reviews can create efficiencies on both sides of the marketplace,” Prasad Vana, one of the authors of the study, said in a statement. “The hope is that AI can benefit reviewers facing larger writing workloads and consumers who have to sort through so much content about products.”

Reviews and machine learning

The researchers took on two challenges for this goal. First, writing an algorithm that could write original and human-quality product reviews using a set of product features. The next task was to see whether the algorithm could be adapted to generate new reviews for products from a large number of existing reviews. To narrow their work, they focused only on wine and beer reviews.

As the code couldn’t actually taste the beer or the wine, the researchers trained the algorithm on hundreds of thousands of published wine and beer reviews. And it turns out it was a big success. For example, one of the results read: “Pretty dark for a rosé, and full-bodied, with cherry, raspberry, vanilla and spice flavors. It’s dry with good acidity” — which sounds pretty enticing.

The algorithm first used previous reviews to learn the structure and style of one. Then, to generate its own, it was given the specifics of the wine or the beer, such as the brewery’s name, the style, the alcohol percentage, and price. Based on these, the AI found existing reviews, took commonly used adjectives, and used them for its reviews.

The researchers also tested the performance of the program. They picked one human and one AI-generated review each for 300 wines and human reviews and one AI reviews each for 69 beers. Then they asked a group of human test subjects to read both versions and check whether they could tell which was which. In most cases, they couldn’t.

However, the algorithm has significant limitations. For example, it may not be able to predict the flavor profile of a drink that wasn’t sampled by humans and described by human writers. That’s why the team insists in the paper that code shouldn’t replace professional product reviewers and instead make the tasks of producing and reading the material more efficient.

“It’s interesting to imagine how this could benefit restaurants that cannot afford sommeliers or independent sellers on online platforms who may sell hundreds of products,” Vana said.

The study was published in the International Journal of Research in Marketing.

share Share

Why Paris Is Leaving Cars Behind for Bikes

Paris has reinvented itself as a cyclist’s paradise, moving from car-dominated streets to a city crisscrossed by bike lanes.

Pluto and its Moon Charon Formed Through a Cosmic "Kiss and Capture"

Until now, the thinking was that Pluto and Charon formed like Earth and our Moon. New research has flipped that script.

Ancient Rome's lead air pollution may have dropped average IQ by up to 3 points

Ancient Rome’s relentless lead pollution may have dimmed the intellect of its citizens, leaving a toxic legacy that survives in today's Greenland ice sheet.

Scientists uncover mystery volcano whose eruption plunged Earth into global cooling 200 years ago

In the 19th-century, one volcanic eruption cooled Earth's climate. Now, we know what happened.

Can AI help us create a universal flu vaccine? These researchers believe so

A universal flu vaccine would be a game changer. Could artificial intelligence help us defeat influenza once and for all?

Scientists find two peaks of aging: At 44 and 60

Researchers uncover molecular turning points that shape health in midlife and beyond.

Twins were the norm for our ancient primate ancestors. Why did we stop?

Twins are pretty rare, accounting for just 3% of births in the US these days. But new research shows that for primates 60 million years ago, giving birth to twins was the norm.

Archaeologists discover 2000-year-old 'Great Wall of Siberia'

The wall measured eight meters tall and ten meters wide.

Scientists Uncover the Ideal Physique for Keeping a Hula Hoop Spinning

The science of hula hooping offers insights into energy, robotics, and human movement.

Huge Study Links Ayahuasca to Mental Health Benefits—But It’s Not for Everyone

Naturalistic use of this Amazonian brew shows potential mental health benefits, but with risks.