homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Bee-killing pesticides offer negligible benefits to soy farmers -- but farmers are not convinced

These pesticides are threatening bee populations, while providing marginal benefits at most.

Mihai Andrei
October 28, 2019 @ 10:34 pm

share Share

The new research concludes that a popular (and controversial) class of pesticides, neonicotinoids, has “negligible” benefits for farmers.

Neonicotinoids are the most widely used insecticides worldwide. They are typically deployed as preventive seed treatments in many grain and oilseed crops (including soybeans). But the scientific data on how useful this actually is, at least in the case of soy, is surprisingly thin.

Spyros Mourtzinis, a postdoctoral research fellow at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, was surprised to see how scarce information is on how useful these pesticides really are. The more he looked at the literature, the more he realized that the data doesn’t seem to back this up.

Along with 22 other authors, he set out to analyze nearly 200 field studies on the effects of neonicotinoids on soybean yields. They found that half of the soy crops in the US use the pesticide as a preventive measure — but without yielding substantial benefits, researchers found.

The results showed that, on average, treated crops produced 2 additional bushels per acre, compared to non-treated crops. A bushel sells for around $9, whereas the insecticide costs around $4 per acre. So you end up, on average, with an extra profit of around $15 per acre — which, while more than zero, is not exactly remarkable. In fact, it’s such a slim margin that the new study suggests that it’s not a best management practice, and is oftentimes used unnecessarily — it should only be used on fields that have a specific pest history, researchers argue.

“We’ve documented the costs and the downsides of neonicotinoids,” said Christian Krupke, an entomology professor at Purdue University, who was one of the 23 researchers who authored a study on the topic.

“So the question we asked with this study was, what are the benefits? Do these insecticides pay off for growers? Do they prevent pest damage? And our findings are that the benefits are negligible.”

Shawn P. Conley, a soybean specialist at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and also an author comments:

“I went into the project assuming this practice would have greater national effects; however, the data speaks for itself,” says Conley. “There are many agronomic factors such as early planting, narrow row spacing and seeding rate that farmers can implement that would play a greater role than neonicotinoids in maximizing economic yield.”

It’s not just that the process isn’t effective in most cases — it has a damaging effect on a number of pollinators, and potentially the entire ecosystems. Numerous studies have shown the negative effect that neonicotinoids can have, and that’s something farmers should account for in the future.

“Furthermore, the non-target impacts of the neonicotinoids used as seed treatments have been documented in dozens of studies by scientists all over the world. These impacts affect a wide range of organisms ranging from pollinators like honey bees to aquatic insects and the birds that depend on them for food,” concludes Krupke.

The study has been published in Scientific Reports.

share Share

A Brain Implant Just Turned a Woman’s Thoughts Into Speech in Near Real Time

This tech restores speech in real time for people who can’t talk, using only brain signals.

Using screens in bed increases insomnia risk by 59% — but social media isn’t the worst offender

Forget blue light, the real reason screens disrupt sleep may be simpler than experts thought.

Beetles Conquered Earth by Evolving a Tiny Chemical Factory

There are around 66,000 species of rove beetles and one researcher proposes it's because of one special gland.

We Should Start Worrying About Space Piracy. Here's Why This Could be A Big Deal

“We are arguing that it’s already started," say experts.

An Experimental Drug Just Slashed Genetic Heart Risk by 94%

One in 10 people carry this genetic heart risk. There's never been a treatment — until now.

We’re Getting Very Close to a Birth Control Pill for Men

Scientists may have just cracked the code for male birth control.

A New Antibiotic Was Hiding in Backyard Dirt and It Might Save Millions

A new antibiotic works when others fail.

Researchers Wake Up Algae That Went Dormant Before the First Pyramids

Scientists have revived 7,000-year-old algae from Baltic Sea sediments, pushing the limits of resurrection ecology.

A Fossil So Strange Scientists Think It’s From a Completely New Form of Life

This towering mystery fossil baffled scientists for 180 Years and it just got weirder.

ChatGPT Seems To Be Shifting to the Right. What Does That Even Mean?

ChatGPT doesn't have any political agenda but some unknown factor is causing a subtle shift in its responses.