homehome Home chatchat Notifications


These ancient farmers learned how to surf and turf — while almost no one else did

Most communities changed. This one didn't.

Mihai Andrei
October 30, 2023 @ 7:49 pm

share Share

If you had to pick one practice that changed the human lifestyle, it’s probably farming. Everything changed once people started to farm. The hunter-gatherer lifestyle was over, settlements started becoming more permanent and, of course, what humans ate changed dramatically. Even in coastal areas, people almost completely stopped cooking fish once they started farming crops and animals. But exceptions do exist.

Intrepid farmers who arrived on Northern Europe’s Baltic learned to get the best of both worlds: they stayed true to their farming but developed a mixed diet that embraced both fish and domesticated animal products. Which begs the question: why did they still fish while the others did not?

neolithic community farming
AI-generated image.

“How prehistoric farming became established in Northern Europe, a region that supported dense populations of hunter-gatherer-fishers, has concerned archaeologists for over a century,” York University researchers note in their study.

The study aimed to understand how the transition from hunting-gathering-fishing to farming affected culinary practices in Northern Europe (from Denmark to Finland). The study focused on the analysis of organic residue found in over 1,000 pottery vessels from both hunter-gatherer-fisher and early agricultural sites.

Despite the transition to farming, there was a surprising continuity in the use of aquatic foods and wild plants. Both hunter-gatherer-fishers and farmers used pottery in similar ways, suggesting a hybrid lifestyle where people farmed, but also foraged, fished, and hunted.

The analysis, which involved a process called gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, shows the different types of organic substances the fats and lipids originated from. Remarkably, 50% of the farmers’ pottery contained fish-based residues, and 5% of them contained traces of dairy.

depiction of research pottery
Residues on ancient pottery were the crux of this study. AI-generated image (DALL-E).

Unfortunately, we still don’t know why people in this particular area continued to have a mixed diet, unlike other populations at the time. Professor Oliver Craig, Director of the BioArCh Lab at the University of York, where the study was conducted, said:

“Our findings suggest that early farmers moved to this region rich in aquatic resources and adapted their economy and daily habits, such as diet and cooking practices, by observing indigenous hunter-gatherer-fishers they encountered. While this might seem like an obvious and logical strategy, it is in significant contrast to virtually all other Early Neolithic sites that are located in coastal areas, where we see no evidence that they made use of marine resources.”

“We may never know for sure why these early agriculturalists embraced a fish diet while farmers in other regions comprehensively rejected aquatic resources. So far, genetic studies suggest there was very little intermarriage between farmers and hunter-gatherers, however, the archaeological record suggests that the hunter-gatherer-fisher population was particularly well-established in this area when the first farmers arrived from Central Europe and the Eurasian Steppe. Perhaps these communities exerted a strong influence on new arrivals resulting in an element of cultural blending between the two groups.”

Co-author of the study, Harry Robson from the Department of Archaeology at the University of York said this shows that the transition from foraging to farming was not that homogeneous, but was rather a complex and nuanced process.

“It is intriguing that, aside from the Danube Gorges, this is the only region in Europe where this practice takes place. Equally, whilst it has long been recognized that the hunter-gatherer-fishers of the Ertebølle culture interacted with farmers across a frontier zone, we have the first widespread evidence that commodities, including dairy products, were exchanged,” Robson says.

There are many unanswered questions regarding this transition, says Dr Alexandre Lucquin, also an author of the study. But one thing’s for sure: once this transition happened, humanity would never be the same again. Maybe studies like this one can, in time, help us understand what happened.

“There are many unanswered questions surrounding why people in Europe made such a large-scale and definitive shift to farming at this time. Perhaps they believed this new lifestyle offered more predictable resources,” Lucquin concludes.

“Once the Neolithic revolution began there was no going back for humanity and we may never really know what happened to the last hunter-gatherers of Europe.”

The study was published in PNAS.

share Share

Tennis May Add Nearly 10 Years to Your Life and Most People Are Ignoring It

Could a weekly match on the court be the secret to a longer, healthier life?

Humans Have Been Reshaping Earth with Fire for at Least 50,000 Years

Fossil charcoal reveals early humans’ growing impact on the carbon cycle before the Ice Age.

The Strangest Microbe Ever Found Straddles The Line Between Life and Non-Life

A newly discovered archaeon blurs the boundary between cells and viruses.

This $8750 Watch Was Designed for Space and Could Finally Replace Apollo-era Omega Watches

An audacious new timepiece dares to outshine Omega’s legacy in space

The Brain May Make New Neurons in Adulthood and Even Old Age

Researchers identify the birthplace of new brain cells well into late adulthood.

Your gut has a secret weapon against 'forever chemicals': microbes

Our bodies have some surprising allies sometimes.

High IQ People Are Strikingly Better at Forecasting the Future

New study shows intelligence shapes our ability to forecast life events accurately.

Cheese Before Bed Might Actually Be Giving You Nightmares

Eating dairy or sweets late at night may fuel disturbing dreams, new study finds.

Scientists Ranked the Most Hydrating Drinks and Water Didn't Win

Milk is more hydrating than water. Here's why.

Methane Leaks from Fossil Fuels Hit Record Highs. And We're Still Looking the Other Way

Powerful leaks, patchy action, and untapped fixes keep methane near record highs in 2024.