homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Book Review: Heretics! The Wondrous (and Dangerous) Beginnings of Modern Philosophy

Heretics! has what it takes to become a classic, or even better yet -- pioneer a new literary genre.

Mihai Andrei
June 29, 2017 @ 8:55 pm

share Share

Heretics Book Review

Heretics!
By Steven Nadler, Ben Nadler
Princeton University Press, 192pages | Buy on Amazon

With its delightful visuals and simplistic way of presenting complex topics, Heretics! has what it takes to become a classic, or even better yet — pioneer a new literary genre.

It’s extremely rare to come across a book that’s innovative in form as well as in content, but I think Heretics! just deserves those accolades. Masterfully mixing a comic book style with complex notions from science and philosophy, Heretics! manages to charm and educate at the same time, and it does all this in style.

Reading about 17th-century philosophy sounds like a daunting task. But going through a graphic novel, sprinkled with delightful jokes and lovable characters is definitely more attractive. You learn just a bit about people such as Descartes, Leibniz, or Newton. You get the feel of how they were feeling in the religion-dominated historic context of their time, and how they might have felt about each other in terms of ideas and philosophy. Most remarkably, it does all this while being cute. This is where I feel Heretics! shines most: it’s fun for everyone, whether you’re a child, a philosophy undergrad, or just someone who wants to read about these gargantuan personalities who shaped how we think for centuries to come. It has something to offer to all of us. It’s a neat way to get you cracking in the complex and often bizarre world of philosophy.

Can you guess who this person is, and what kind of trouble he was referring to? Image credits: Nadler & Nadler.

Of course, you won’t come out with a philosophy degree from the book. If anything, you’ll come out with a thirst to know more about the revolutionary theories of Spinoza, for example. You’ll learn how much of a chain the Church was to philosophers, how they tried to mix in their personal beliefs with the mandatory existence of God, and how they reached surprising conclusions working with drastically insufficient information. It’s an unlikely testament to their brilliance.

The cartoonish style of the panels highlights that this book wants to be approachable. It wants to be read and enjoyed by everybody, discussing complex topics in a fun way. It wants to show you the start of modern philosophy while putting a smile on your face. It’s an approach (mixing serious stuff with humor and graphics) which I hope to see in more books.

share Share

The Rise and Fall of Civilizations: What the Bronze Age Collapse Teaches Us About Today

Eric Cline masterfully unpacks what followed after the collapse of Bronze Age civilizations, offering lessons for today.

How the first pandemic in history shook the Roman Empire

In his book 'Pox Romana,' Colin Elliott delves into the devastating effects of the Antonine Plague, a pandemic that might have hastened the decline of one of history's greatest empires.

The Journalist's Predicament: what keeps journalists going against the odds?

An important book about an often overlooked problem.

The essential read on plastics — a material that changed the world

We need to talk about plastic — and this is an excellent starting point.

Book review: On Niccolò Machiavelli

Gabriele Pedulla's 'On Niccolò Machiavelli' unravels Machiavelli's deep insights into power, ethics, and human nature.

How to Think Like Shakespeare

"My conviction is that education must be about thinking -- not training a set of specific skills."

Buzzworthy: bees' minds show remarkable depth and richness

Are we prepared to consider that bees may have a form of consciousness? Well... we'd best get prepared.

Climate change: 'The Future We Choose' by Christiana Figueres

The world faces an unprecedented crisis as global temperatures continue to rise, leading to devastating environmental impacts such as rising sea levels, extreme weather events, and species extinction. COP27, the 27th Conference of the Parties of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, was an important event that took place in November 2022. This year’s […]

Do animals dream? Quite possibly, and the implications are huge

This question may have an answer we're not ready to deal with.

Dinopedia: A Brief Compendium of Dinosaur Lore

A brief and to the point overview of all things dinosaurs.