homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Book review: 'The Quantum Moment'

How the quantum moment "overturned basic beliefs about space and time, causality and reality, and exposed as mistaken many fundamental cultural and philosophical assumptions."

Tibi Puiu
March 17, 2015 @ 3:16 pm

share Share

The quantum moment

“The Quantum Moment: How Planck, Bohr, Einstein, and Heisenberg Taught Us to Love Uncertainty”
By  Robert P. Crease, Alfred Scharff Goldhaber
W. W. Norton & Company, 352pp | Buy on Amazon

The idea that energy comes in finite packets of energy, known as quanta, instead of infinitely divisible quantities was a monumental breakthrough in physics. Little did Max Planck, the physicist who first posited the concept of quantization of radiation in 1900, what kind of impact his discovery would have. A new age of physicists ushered following Planck’s seminal paper, one that would topple Newton’s entrenched values and a deterministic worldview. This was the beginning of the quantum moment, culminating with the advent of quantum mechanics – a body of work that describes the queer world of the nanoscale.

Robert Crease (philosopher) and Alfred Goldhaber (physicists), both professors at Stony Brook University have for the past six years been co-teaching an unconventional course on quantum physics. Not just a physics lecture, their course is focused on an aspect that’s often ignored: how quantum physics has entered popular imagery and language. Their experience has inspired the two to author a highly entertaining book called “The Quantum Moment”.

Yes, the book covers a history of quantum physics and thus a marvelous job at explaining some of the most fundamental findings. But it’s far more than this. Taking turns, the authors  explore the quantum’s manifestation in everything from art and sculpture to the prose of John Updike. In physical terms, quantum leap signifies the  change of an electron from one quantum state to another within an atom. Today, however it has long crossed into the realm of popular culture. Journalists often use it to describe great progress. For instance, there’s a sculpture in  River Severn, Shrewsbury, UK called the Quantum Leap that’s dedicated to Charles Darwin, in recognition for the formidable leap in consciousness he offered humanity. Google Quantum Leap and the first thing that pops is a wikipedia entry about an old TV series.

Quantum physics is also abused. The multiverse, the uncertainty principle and even poor ol’ Schrodinger’s cat are often thrown about in discourses, when other metaphors might be more appropriate. Then there’s what the authors call fruit-loopery or blunt misinterpretations of quantum physics, often encountered in new age dialogues.

The book can be quite technical for neophytes, but you can skip some passages without losing the essence. Those concerned with the science will rejoice. But, again, this isn’t necessarily a book about the technical aspects of the quantum moment. The authors merely set out the right context, so they can then dissect the philosophical and cultural impact. After all, you’ll find how the quantum moment “overturned basic beliefs about space and time, causality and reality, and exposed as mistaken many fundamental cultural and philosophical assumptions.”

As Updike suggests, we keep asking for the material things that the quantum is going to give us through technology, but it has already maybe done much more so: it has changed us spiritually. The books explores all this and more. Art majors, physicists and laymen will all find something to their liking.

share Share

The Rise and Fall of Civilizations: What the Bronze Age Collapse Teaches Us About Today

Eric Cline masterfully unpacks what followed after the collapse of Bronze Age civilizations, offering lessons for today.

How the first pandemic in history shook the Roman Empire

In his book 'Pox Romana,' Colin Elliott delves into the devastating effects of the Antonine Plague, a pandemic that might have hastened the decline of one of history's greatest empires.

The Journalist's Predicament: what keeps journalists going against the odds?

An important book about an often overlooked problem.

The essential read on plastics — a material that changed the world

We need to talk about plastic — and this is an excellent starting point.

Book review: On Niccolò Machiavelli

Gabriele Pedulla's 'On Niccolò Machiavelli' unravels Machiavelli's deep insights into power, ethics, and human nature.

How to Think Like Shakespeare

"My conviction is that education must be about thinking -- not training a set of specific skills."

Buzzworthy: bees' minds show remarkable depth and richness

Are we prepared to consider that bees may have a form of consciousness? Well... we'd best get prepared.

Climate change: 'The Future We Choose' by Christiana Figueres

The world faces an unprecedented crisis as global temperatures continue to rise, leading to devastating environmental impacts such as rising sea levels, extreme weather events, and species extinction. COP27, the 27th Conference of the Parties of the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change, was an important event that took place in November 2022. This year’s […]

Do animals dream? Quite possibly, and the implications are huge

This question may have an answer we're not ready to deal with.

Dinopedia: A Brief Compendium of Dinosaur Lore

A brief and to the point overview of all things dinosaurs.