homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Philosopher outsmarts brain scientist in decades-long consciousness bet

The mystery of consciousness still remains elusive.

Fermin Koop
June 28, 2023 @ 10:43 pm

share Share

consciousness
Credit: Pixabay.

Over twenty-five years ago, within the realm of consciousness studies, neuroscientist Christof Koch and philosopher David Chalmers embarked on a captivating bet.

Koch believed that the brain mechanisms leading to consciousness would be discovered by 2023. The deadline has now been met and Kock conceded his defeat. He now owes Chalmers a case of wine.

A captivating bet

Christof Koch (left) and David Chalmers
Christof Koch (left) and David Chalmers.

Koch has dedicated his career to exploring the fundamental aspects of consciousness since the 1980s. Back then, new emerging technologies, such as magnetic resonance imaging, looked like they were on the cusp of unraveling the mysteries of the human mind.

“I believed that 25 years down the line? Piece of cake,” he told Nature about the bet.

The wager had been forgotten until a science journalist, Per Snaprud, found a recording of an interview with Chalmers, who mentioned the bet and the case of wine that was at stake. Recently, Koch and Chalmers met at the Association for the Scientific Study of Consciousness (ASSC) meeting, where Koch declared the philosopher to be the winner.

Consciousness covers every aspect of an individual’s experiences, including sensations of taste, hearing, and touch, among others, Chalmers told Nature. It’s the essence that fills our lives with significance and meaning. Despite a lot of work, the scientific community has yet to understand how the human brain generates consciousness.

The mysteries of consciousness

Chalmers and Koch are both part of a project supported by the Templeton World Charity Foundation, which seeks to accelerate consciousness research by fostering collaboration between rival researchers. Through it, academics would engage in antagonistic experiments to scrutinize different hypotheses on consciousness.

During the ASSC conference, the outcome of one of these experiments was unveiled, comparing two theories of consciousness: Integrated Information Theory (IIT) and Global Network Workspace Theory (GNWT).

According to IIT, consciousness is believed to originate from a particular arrangement of neural connections, referred to as a “structure,” within the posterior cortex. On the other hand, GNWT proposes that consciousness emerges as information is shared across a network of interconnected brain regions. The prefrontal cortex assumes a prominent role here as well.

While the results of the experiment are yet to undergo peer review, they didn’t align perfectly with either theory, leaving the quest for understanding consciousness still open. GNWT fared a bit worse than IIT, Lucia Melloni, one of the researchers involved, told Nature, but this doesn’t mean IIT is true. Instead, she said proponents have to rethink the proposed mechanisms.

Koch agreed there’s still plenty of room for debate regarding the question of how the brain builds a universe inside of our mind. However, he said he would be willing to make the same bet today.

“Twenty-five years from now is realistic because the techniques are improving and, given my age, I can’t wait much longer than 25 years,” he told Nature.

share Share

A Brain Implant Just Turned a Woman’s Thoughts Into Speech in Near Real Time

This tech restores speech in real time for people who can’t talk, using only brain signals.

Using screens in bed increases insomnia risk by 59% — but social media isn’t the worst offender

Forget blue light, the real reason screens disrupt sleep may be simpler than experts thought.

We Should Start Worrying About Space Piracy. Here's Why This Could be A Big Deal

“We are arguing that it’s already started," say experts.

An Experimental Drug Just Slashed Genetic Heart Risk by 94%

One in 10 people carry this genetic heart risk. There's never been a treatment — until now.

We’re Getting Very Close to a Birth Control Pill for Men

Scientists may have just cracked the code for male birth control.

A New Antibiotic Was Hiding in Backyard Dirt and It Might Save Millions

A new antibiotic works when others fail.

Researchers Wake Up Algae That Went Dormant Before the First Pyramids

Scientists have revived 7,000-year-old algae from Baltic Sea sediments, pushing the limits of resurrection ecology.

A Fossil So Strange Scientists Think It’s From a Completely New Form of Life

This towering mystery fossil baffled scientists for 180 Years and it just got weirder.

ChatGPT Seems To Be Shifting to the Right. What Does That Even Mean?

ChatGPT doesn't have any political agenda but some unknown factor is causing a subtle shift in its responses.

This Freshwater Fish Can Live Over 120 Years and Shows No Signs of Aging. But It Has a Problem

An ancient freshwater species may be quietly facing a silent collapse.