homehome Home chatchat Notifications


Could Exxon and other oil companies be liable for a RICO case just like big tobacco?

In 2006, the US court found the tobacco industry guilty of a decades-long racketeering enterprise in which it conspired to deceive the public about the dangers of smoking. The tobacco companies were ordered to buy newspaper ads detailing smoking's health effects and to stop using such descriptions as "low tar," "light," ultra light," "mild" or "natural" that might imply that they are less dangerous than other cigarettes. They were also ordered to pay $10 billion in fines. Speaking for ThinkProgress, Sharon Y. Eubanks - the leader of the Justice Department team that prosecuted the landmark lawsuit against big tobacco - says the Department of Justice should investigate Exxon and possibly other fossil fuel industry players (Koch *cough) for a similar claim, only much worse. The conspiracy isn't only against smokers' health, it's against all life on Earth.

Tibi Puiu
October 20, 2015 @ 4:28 pm

share Share

In 2006, the US court found the tobacco industry guilty of a decades-long racketeering enterprise in which it conspired to deceive the public about the dangers of smoking. The tobacco companies were ordered to buy newspaper ads detailing smoking’s health effects and to stop using such descriptions as “low tar,” “light,” ultra light,” “mild” or “natural” that might imply that they are less dangerous than other cigarettes. They were also ordered to pay $10 billion in fines. Speaking for ThinkProgress, Sharon Y. Eubanks – the leader of the Justice Department team that prosecuted the landmark lawsuit against big tobacco – says the Department of Justice should investigate Exxon and possibly other fossil fuel industry players (Koch *cough) for a similar claim, only much worse. The conspiracy isn’t only against smokers’ health, it’s against all life on Earth.

Exxon Mobil. Image: Politico

Image: Politico

Previously, ZME Science reported Exxon had data which showed a strong link between greenhouse emissions and climate change as early as 1981, a former Exxon researcher revealed. Since then, Exxon’s position has been increasingly against acknowledging that man-made climate change is a real, immediate threat – which, of course, would imply they bear a large share of the blame. It also took active action. For instance, 9 out of 10 climate change denial papers were funded one way or the other by Exxon.  Over the years, Exxon spent more than $30m on thinktanks and researchers that promoted climate denial, according to Greenpeace.

“What it shows is that Exxon knew years earlier than James Hansen’s testimony to Congress that climate change was a reality; that it accepted the reality, instead of denying the reality as they have done publicly, and to such an extent that it took it into account in their decision making, in making their economic calculation,” said Alyssa Bernstein of the Institute for Applied and Professional Ethics at Ohio University

“One thing that occurs to me is the behavior of the tobacco companies denying the connection between smoking and lung cancer for the sake of profits, but this is an order of magnitude greater moral offence, in my opinion, because what is at stake is the fate of the planet, humanity, and the future of civilisation, not to be melodramatic.”

A hilarious old Exxon ad.

A hilarious old Exxon ad.

This news was bundled together with other evidence showing how companies like Exxon, BP, Shell and Peabody Energy have tried to deceive the public about the realities and risks of climate change, under a report called “The Climate Deception Dossier”. All of this, Eubanks thinks, should be enough to begin the prosecution of Exxon and other fossil companies engaged in similar practices.

“It appears to me, based on what we know so far, that there was a concerted effort by Exxon and others to confuse the public on climate change,” Eubanks said. “They were actively denying the impact of human-caused carbon emissions, even when their own research showed otherwise.”

“I’m not an environmental lawyer. But I know it’s important…This is more important than just running a case. That much I’m sure of.”

Indeed, the parallel between the fossil industry and big tobacco is uncanny. The Guardian reports two members of Congress have already asked for a federal investigation into whether ExxonMobil broke the law by intentionally obscuring the truth about climate change. But that’s far from enough. A case of this magnitude is difficult to put on the table without political backing. Right now, the political climate in the US might not allow for such a thing to happen. Don’t act surprised, however, when you hear of a huge RICO case against Exxon and the gang sometime in the near future.

share Share

Archaeologists Uncover Creepy Floor Made From Bones Hidden Beneath a Medieval Dutch House

Archaeologists uncover a mysterious flooring style in the Netherlands, built with cattle bones.

This 5,500-year-old Kish tablet is the oldest written document

Beer, goats, and grains: here's what the oldest document reveals.

A Huge, Lazy Black Hole Is Redefining the Early Universe

Astronomers using the James Webb Space Telescope have discovered a massive, dormant black hole from just 800 million years after the Big Bang.

Did Columbus Bring Syphilis to Europe? Ancient DNA Suggests So

A new study pinpoints the origin of the STD to South America.

The Magnetic North Pole Has Shifted Again. Here’s Why It Matters

The magnetic North pole is now closer to Siberia than it is to Canada, and scientists aren't sure why.

For better or worse, machine learning is shaping biology research

Machine learning tools can increase the pace of biology research and open the door to new research questions, but the benefits don’t come without risks.

This Babylonian Student's 4,000-Year-Old Math Blunder Is Still Relatable Today

More than memorializing a math mistake, stone tablets show just how advanced the Babylonians were in their time.

Sixty Years Ago, We Nearly Wiped Out Bed Bugs. Then, They Started Changing

Driven to the brink of extinction, bed bugs adapted—and now pesticides are almost useless against them.

LG’s $60,000 Transparent TV Is So Luxe It’s Practically Invisible

This TV screen vanishes at the push of a button.

Couple Finds Giant Teeth in Backyard Belonging to 13,000-year-old Mastodon

A New York couple stumble upon an ancient mastodon fossil beneath their lawn.